SPRING 2025
ISSUE 02

Subway Portraits:
The Struggle Behind MTA Style

SIRUI MA



Last year, the photographer Sirui Ma collaborated with dozens of MTA train conductors in New York City on a series of portraits that capture the dignity, style, and authority that the unionized operators bring to their job. This project was collected in Subway Portraits, which captures these small gestures of autonomy that, in fact, have a long history.

The shape of the work process for many of the train operators and station agents in the MTA – almost everyone besides the engineers and those in higher density sheds, garages, and workstations – is one of relative isolation. Though some organizers rode from station to station along a line, signing up sleepy figure after sleepy figure in some quiet outer borough ticket booth, most of the organizing in the 1930s had to pass through off-the-clock networks and relationships, notably the community of Irish immigrants who ran the trains. The Catholic Church was an obvious center of gravity, but so were the Irish Republican dances. Mike Quill, the longtime leader of the Transit Workers Union (TWU), was well known as an emcee of these dances before he developed a reputation as a leader on the job.


Like many organizing drives in the 1930s and 1940s, the primary struggle was against the autocratic power of management. Workers’ uniforms were a particularly exacting site of discipline. The clothes themselves were extraordinarily expensive and had to be purchased from company-designated stores. Rumor had it that managers received kickbacks for these mandated purchases. Workers were subject to the humiliation of regular uniform inspections – one of countless opportunities for managers to strip them of pay and hours. Joshua Freeman writes that discipline could be meted out for “something as small as a missing button.”

One of the first demands won by the nascent TWU was to seize some control over how uniforms were made, purchased, and worn. The union logo was to be featured prominently and the fit henceforth made in shops organized by the Amalgamated Clothing Workers. As the union paper put it, the “drab, prison-like outfit” was “replaced by snappy, neat and durable clothes which are indicative of transit labor’s liberation.”—BEN MABIE