SPRING 2025
ISSUE 02

Yet It Moves

EDITORIAL COLLECTIVE

1 This partakes of a longer tradition. Mike Davis wrote, in the wake of Reagan’s reelection: “In no other capitalist country is mass political abstentionism as fully developed as in the United States, where a ‘silent majority’ of the working class has sat out more than half the elections of the last century.” Prisoners of the American Dream: Politics and Economy in the History of the US Working Class (London and New York: Verso, 2018), 3.

2 Martin Glaberman, Wartime Strikes: The Struggle Against the No-Strike Pledge in the UAW During World War II (Detroit: Bewick Editions, 1980), 123–24.

3 Ignatiev draws this from the Communist Manifesto, which declares that the worker under capitalism is “compelled to face with sober senses, his real conditions of life, and his relations with his kind.” The concrete examples he provides concern the election of union stewards and committeemen, where outcomes that would appear to reflect “backwardness” can be shown to have a rational basis.

4 Noel Ignatiev, “The Backward Workers,” in Treason to Whiteness Is Loyalty to Humanity, edited by Geert Dhondt, Zhandarka Kurti, and Jarrod Shanahan (London and New York: Verso, 2022), 179.

5 Ignatiev, “The Backward Workers,” 180.

6 Gramsci’s original comments: “The crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying and the new cannot be born; in this interregnum a great variety of morbid symptoms appear.” Some of the most incisive commentary came from Mike Davis: “Everyone is quoting Gramsci on the interregnum, but that assumes that something new will be or could be born,” he wrote. “I doubt it.” Davis preferred the diagnosis of a “ruling class brain tumour” to explain the abundant morbidity of our times. See Mike Davis, “Thanatos Triumphant,” New Left Review: Sidecar, March 7, 2022, available from https://newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/thanatos-triumphant.

7 While racism has accompanied the development of capitalism wherever its processes of exploitation have taken root most intensively, for Rawick, “there is more than the simple equation that the more capitalist a society, the more developed its racism. Racism fed on underground streams of sensibilities. It was embedded within the historical process itself. Both racism and slavery were part of the totality of relations that developed into modern capitalism.” George Rawick, From Sundown to Sunup: The Making of the Black Community (Westport: Greenwood Publishing Company, 1972), 128.

8 “Where the movement will go in general we cannot anticipate with precision. Yet, with Galileo, the least we can say is that something is moving.” George Rawick, “Potere Nero e Lotte Operaie,” in U.S.A. / Dalle Strade Alle Fabbriche, trans. Ferruccio Gambino (Milano: Libreria Feltrinelli, 1968), 17. Ferruccio Gambino also acted as real-time translator during the 1967 lecture from which this text was composed. See also, Ferruccio Gambino, “George Rawick in Europe: a Remembrance,” in George Rawick, Listening to Revolt: Selected Writings, (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr, 2010), 143.










9 Ferruccio Gambino, “In Memory of George P. Rawick: Sizing Up the Magnitude of Dismantling Racism,” 1999: Zeitschrift für Sozialgeschichte des 20 und 21 Jahrhunderts (1991): 108.


The working class, if it could be said to have done anything at all on November 5, did not vote for Donald Trump as much as simply not vote at all.1 The pollsters and pundits willing to acknowledge as much may sneer that the abstentionism of working people contributes to their powerlessness, especially in an election where “democracy” was (yet again) on the ballot. But this charge ignores the reality that large swathes of US society, touched by no union affiliation whatsoever, expressed clear disdain for the options on the table and thus admitted a clearer principle in politics than was afforded by the democratic spectacle that is said to be its basis. 

“The view is false both in unions and in the society generally, that power resides with voters in proportion to numbers of votes,” wrote Martin Glaberman in a book published the year of Ronald Reagan’s election. The famous political abstentionism of the working class in the United States, for Glaberman, is no “sign of backwardness.” It instead represents a “cynical but accurate” assessment by workers of the electoral process as a whole. “Union leaders, politicians, businessmen, intellectuals are seen as ‘them,’ as opposed to ‘us,’” he continues. “The kind of satisfactions workers can expect to receive from ‘them’ tends to be marginal. Things may get a little better or a little worse, but the fundamental reality of life at work is not likely to change.”2 The vague assurances pitched by the 2020 Biden/Harris campaign to highly particularized sets of elite donors and swing state voters, that “nothing fundamental will change,” had universal implications.

One year after the publication of Glaberman’s book, and with Reagan inaugurated, Noel Ignatiev advanced a controversial thesis: “When a significant body of workers or members of an oppressed group is offered a choice between several possibilities which they perceive as realistic, they always make the right choice.” Such an idea might seem outlandish on its face, and Ignatiev is careful to clarify its scope. It does not mean that workers will always vote according to their interests in national elections, but rather more discrete and narrow decisions. The foundation for this claim is the workers’ “total attachment to reality,” a psychological characteristic of the exploited class.3

By their actions people shape the future. Workers as a class, unlike revolutionary intellectuals (and the latter not as much as they would like to believe), do not choose between various futures based solely on what is desirable. A weighty factor in their calculations is what they consider possible.4

This attachment to reality does not, of course, inoculate workers against the ignorance and nonsense that confronts and comes to fill the average person’s head beyond the workplace. “What the worker sees realistically,” argues Ignatiev, “is that portion of the world that touches on him and that he can do something about.” The worker, like other oppressed people, only makes it through the other parts of life with the aid of elaborate systems for keeping reality at bay, or denying it altogether. “When a relatively rapid deterioration of conditions cracks the effectiveness of the denial mechanism at a time when no way out has yet become apparent, there follows the appearance, on a mass scale, symptoms of mental illness. Such is the case in the US today.”5

This diagnosis from 1981 is still prescient. The prevailing notions of politics in the United States today show that even the attachment to reality, the “real conditions of life” that Ignatiev proceeds from, can disintegrate as formations of class rule crumble. Such a situation has led to near incessant evocations of Gramsci’s comments on the morbid symptoms of “the interregnum” to depict present conditions and the prospects for a way out. While comforting, this position tends to harden into outright cynicism.6 Moreover, it doesn’t take us far in understanding what might be possible from below. A politics that adapts to setbacks and prioritizes experimentation and creativity among unlikely sets of actors and under challenging conditions must find a different point of departure in the historical stream of class struggle.


—

At the conclusion of a remarkable overview of the desegregation movement in the US South, dispatched to an audience of some one thousand students in 1967 at the State University in Milan, Italy, the militant historian of slavery, George Rawick, pressed his audience to consider the revolutionary implications of a struggle rather foreign to them. He spoke of the rootedness of racism in the United States and the detrimental and deterrent effects it exercised on large swathes of society, including the official institutions of the labor movement and politics, where discrimination was an intractable social and legal reality.7 But, so long as one kept an ear close enough to the ground, Rawick insisted, possibilities for redressing the processes that maintain the “color line” could be apprehended. While the secular audience of Italian students was not in a position to hear from the partisan forces inside those explosive campaigns for desegregation, they could, through Rawick’s elucidation, begin to understand the key differences between their station in Italy and that of their Black colleagues one continent apart. Rawick ended by offering a curious proposition, out of step with the unilateral assessment of the United States as an immutable hegemon abroad and vanguard of white supremacy at home. Referring to the social and political trajectory of that behemoth, he recalled Galileo’s famous three words, vouchsafed to Earth during his trial by the Roman Catholic inquisition: “Yet it moves.”8

The phrase is not prescriptive. Rather, it names the propulsive force behind renovations in the foundations of American society, outside the orbit of the most visible and repressive layers of official politics, and driven in large part, to date, by the Black proletariat. Is there a dynamic similarly perceptible in the strivings of the working class in the United States today as it confronts the entire weight of US accumulation, and now in light of the prospect of military power being mobilized, or turned inwardly, to discipline labor struggles among migrants and non-migrants alike? As Trump rails against the 14th Amendment, we are reminded that its sweeping rights and protections were not simply institutional outcomes of the revolutionary sequence of the Civil War and Reconstruction era. They mark key victories in the long struggle of what Rawick called the oldest and most experienced section of the US working class: the Black community. Today, they seem to form a barrier not only against the hyper-exploitation of migrant workers and their families, but also the morbid plans for a deeper and more streamlined segmentation of all workers in this country. These rights and protections, however, won’t be defended otherwise than how they were won.

Those attempting to eke out a living in the United States today experience profound rudderlessness. We are confronted at once with a rapid deterioration in standards of living and working conditions and with unstable codes of social communication and political orientation. (The experts label this phenomenon “realignment,” reducing it to the weaker question of party-based affinities, while some leftists term it “dealignment.”) The dynamic is impossible to separate from the question of historical racism and its function in a recongealed ruling-class politics. If, in the past, “white workers had, necessarily, to define themselves by denying that they were part of a larger field of exploitation,” the churn of that field has contributed to a more generalized social vulnerability against which the state appears not as protector of white workers, in particular, but as a guarantor of the exploitation of the entire class.9 Without falling back on the typical predictive posturing that constitutes analysis in these times, it seems clear that Trump’s appeal is rooted in a desire to return to a historical period where the “denial mechanism” is intact, where the state might once again invoke the color line in opposition to the worst forms of exploitation. This desire surely anchors one pole of contemporary racism in its attack on immigrant non-citizens.

As the Trump administration slouches forward, we can expect an irresistible tendency to respond in kind to legal threats against the threadbare framework of political and social rights affecting working people. The laser-like focus on institutions is understandable, given the weakness of workplace protections and the inevitability of serious right-wing efforts to dismantle existing labor law. But the initiatives that follow this instinct – responses to legal decisions, lawsuits, proposed legislation, or electoral tickets – will neither facilitate organizing nor give us a sense of the attitudes and behaviors of workers in relevant sectors or sites. A wholly different orientation is required: one that recognizes the effects that distinct struggles can have among wider layers of workers and one that is, moreover, open to the contradictions and latent possibilities that can puncture a bleak set of circumstances.

A distinct course presents itself through contact with more or less organized expressions of class discontent that we have seen in the months since the election. Strikes by Amazon and Starbucks workers were encouraging, even if they were relatively small and concentrated in only a few areas. These displays of militancy unfolded in sectors and jobs where every available tactic and condition is used to suppress organizing, from old ethnic and linguistic targeting to new forms of surveillance and performance monitoring. They also showed that workplace organizers at Amazon – like those at the Queens warehouse interviewed in this issue – and Starbucks, among the most visible centers of worker initiative in recent years, have maintained a shop-floor presence and can still coordinate large-scale actions. There are other signs among the ranks of unionized federal workers. Locals and rank-and-filers have spearheaded a “Federal Unionists Network” to synchronize efforts at recruitment, training, communication, and possible collective action against the current assaults on civil service. In a moment where many have consigned themselves to the great moving right show, these struggles indicate pockets from which a broader class politics might be built.

The components of this politics will likely involve connections between experienced troublemakers and newly activated layers of frustrated workers, the transmission of a culture of democratic deliberation, a sensitivity to where power might be exercised and the confidence that comes from having waged and won a fight. In other words, it will stem from the people for whom solidarity and militant collective action has, after “weighty calculation” in the ledger of “what is possible,” already been experienced as an entirely rational pursuit. At time of writing, the organized response of the Chicago Teachers Union to the latest wave of ICE raids stands out as an especially swift and comprehensive mobilization to defend workers, students, and the broader community connected to the city’s public schools. It is far from surprising that this union, with its storied recent history of militancy, was so positioned to move. But now that they have forged a model, it becomes available to organized workers everywhere to take up and modify.